Search

    Language Settings
    Select Website Language

    GDPR Compliance

    We use cookies to ensure you get the best experience on our website. By continuing to use our site, you accept our use of cookies, Privacy Policy, and Terms of Service.

    Eight Congress MPs Suspended from Lok Sabha Over Chaos on Naravane Memoir

    3 months ago

    137

    0

    👍 ❤️ 😂 😮 😢 😡

    Eight Members of Parliament from the Congress party were suspended from the Lok Sabha on Tuesday following persistent disruptions during the ongoing Budget Session, triggered by references to the unpublished memoir of former Army Chief General Manoj Mukund Naravane. The suspension came after two consecutive days of disorder in the Lower House, as opposition members clashed with the Chair over the admissibility of material linked to national security matters.

    The MPs who were suspended include Manickam Tagore, Kiran Reddy, Prashant Padole, Hibi Eden, Amarinder Singh Raja Warring, Gurjeet Aujla, S. Venkat Raman and Dean Kuriakose. Parliamentary sources said the action was taken due to repeated disregard for the Speaker’s rulings and continued obstruction of proceedings despite multiple warnings.

    The controversy centres on references made to an unpublished memoir authored by General Naravane, which reportedly contains his account of the 2020 India-China military face-off in eastern Ladakh. Portions of the account had surfaced earlier through a magazine article, sparking debate over claims that political decision-making during the standoff appeared uncertain. The book itself has not yet been released, as it is still under review by the Army for official clearance.

    During the session, Leader of Opposition Rahul Gandhi sought to raise the issue while discussing the President’s address, arguing that the matter had national significance. However, the Speaker ruled that unauthorised or unverified material could not be cited in the House and noted that the subject did not fall within the scope of the ongoing discussion. The Chair also pointed out that established parliamentary procedures require advance notice when making allegations or referencing sensitive documents.

    Despite repeated interventions from the Speaker and senior ministers, the opposition continued to press the issue, leading to a prolonged standoff. On one occasion, the House remained disrupted for over 40 minutes as disagreements escalated over procedural rules. The Speaker cited relevant provisions to underline that only authenticated and permitted material may be placed on record.

    Tensions rose further when Rahul Gandhi attempted to submit a signed copy of the article citing the memoir, a process known as authentication, which is required to affirm the accuracy of a document to the best of a member’s knowledge. Even then, objections were raised on the grounds that the content related to an unpublished and uncleared work, particularly one touching upon defence matters.

    The impasse spilled over into exchanges about decorum, with members of the treasury benches objecting to the language used while addressing the Chair. Parliamentary Affairs Minister Krishna Prasad Tenneti was heard reminding opposition leaders that informal expressions were not acceptable in the House and that respect for the Chair was fundamental to parliamentary functioning.

    Following the suspension, Congress MPs, led by Rahul Gandhi and joined by Priyanka Gandhi Vadra, staged a protest outside the Parliament complex. They alleged that the action was aimed at suppressing debate and curbing the opposition’s right to raise questions of public importance. The party maintained that it was seeking accountability and transparency on issues related to national security and governance.

    The government, on the other hand, defended the Speaker’s decision, stating that parliamentary rules exist to ensure orderly debate and protect sensitive information. Officials emphasised that matters related to defence and military assessments must follow established clearance protocols and cannot be selectively quoted from unpublished material.

    General Naravane has previously stated that his book remains under review and that its publication was deferred after excerpts appeared prematurely. He clarified in earlier public comments that the clearance process was ongoing and that the final content would be released only after due approval.

    The suspension of MPs has once again highlighted the fragile balance between robust debate and procedural discipline in Parliament. With the Budget Session continuing, observers note that sustained disruptions could affect legislative business, including discussions on key policy and economic measures.

    As proceedings resume, it remains to be seen whether dialogue between the government and the opposition can restore normalcy in the House, or whether the standoff over the memoir and related issues will continue to dominate parliamentary discourse in the days ahead.

     
     
    Click here to Read More
    • Share:
    Three Minor Sisters Found Dead in Ghaziabad High-Rise; Police Probe Focuses on Digital Gaming Exposure
    Previous Article
    Three Minor Sisters Found Dead in Ghaziabad High-Rise; Police Probe Focuses on Digital Gaming Exposure
    Next Article
    After Trade Breakthrough, India and US Turn Focus to Critical Minerals as Jaishankar Holds Key Talks in Washington
    After Trade Breakthrough, India and US Turn Focus to Critical Minerals as Jaishankar Holds Key Talks in Washington

    Related Politics Updates:

    Are you sure? You want to delete this comment..! Remove Cancel

    Comments (0)

      Leave a comment

      Send